That Cabernet Might Not Be Good For Your Health After All
March 22, 2016, 6:32 pm     |   Source: npr.org

You`ve probably heard that a little booze a day is good for you. I`ve even said it at parties. "Look at the French," I`ve said gleefully over my own cup. "Wine all the time and they still live to be not a day younger than 82."

I`m sorry to say we`re probably wrong. The evidence that alcohol has any benefit on longevity or heart health is thin, says Dr. Timothy Naimi, a physician and epidemiologist at Boston Medical Center.

He and his colleagues published an analysis 87 of the best research studies on alcohol`s effect on death from any cause in the Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs on Tuesday. "[Our] findings here cast a great deal of skepticism on this long, cherished belief that moderate drinking has a survival advantage," he says.

In these studies, the participants get sorted into categories based on how much alcohol they think they drink. Researchers typically size up occasional, moderate and heavy drinkers against non-drinkers. When you do this, the moderates, one to three drinks a day, usually come out on top. They`re less likely to die early from health problems like heart disease or cancer and injury.



But then it gets very tricky, "because moderate drinkers tend to be very socially advantaged," Naimi says. Moderate drinkers tend to be healthier on average because they`re well-educated and more affluent, not because they`re drinking a bottle of wine a week on average. "[Their] alcohol consumption ends up looking good from a health perspective because they`re already healthy to begin with."

To make things worse, Naimi says that some of the non-drinkers in these studies weren`t always dry. "People in poor health tend to quit drinking," he says. In the studies, those who abstained from alcohol altogether were lumped together with those who quit later in life, bringing down the overall health of the entire group.

Naimi and his colleagues sorted the lifetime nondrinkers from the quitters, controlled for socioeconomic class and reanalyzed the data from all 87 studies. "When we accounted for these biases, moderate drinkers had no survival advantage," Naimi says. "It became a wash either way." Those who imbibe one or three glasses a day appeared to do no better than those who never touch alcohol.



What`s more, Naimi says the group that did the best were the people who had on average one drink every 10 days. "It`s almost homeopathic amounts of alcohol. So it`s extremely unlikely that it`s the alcohol that`s making them look good," he says. The heavy drinkers had the shortest lives on average, which should come as no surprise.

The meta-analysis severs one arm of reasoning why alcohol might be beneficial, says Dr. Jennie Connor, a physician and researcher at the University of Otago in New Zealand who was not involved in the work. "They`ve very successfully investigated one of the many series of problems in this reasoning," she says. "People used studies to say, `Hey, look there`s a benefit [to alcohol], and when we talk about harms we have to balance that against the benefit.` That`s always been a fallacious argument, and it`s really been reduced to nothing now."

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has also given the purported health benefit of alcohol a wary eye. The agency recommends people have no more than one drink a day for women and two a day for men. This refers to the amount imbibed on one day and isn`t meant to be taken as an average over several days. The Dietary Guidelines for Americans suggests people who don`t drink alcohol should not start for health reasons.



Naimi says the biological hypothesis for why alcohol could be good for health has also been eroding. "[Alcohol] raises your good cholesterol. That`s the main biological argument," he says. "But the whole idea that [good cholesterol] causes heart health is going away now." A recent study published in Science showed that people with naturally higher levels of good cholesterol had more cardiovascular diseases than those without.

But still, the notion that alcohol extends our lifespans is a persistent one. According to Connor and Traci Toomey, an alcohol policy researcher at the University of Minnesota, studies supporting the link between moderate drinking and long life have been used to argue against certain alcohol harm reduction policies. "Usually there are proposals of having [health] labels," Toomey says. "[The industry] controls a lot of the messaging around alcohol."

In Connor`s eyes, that messaging has kept the notion alive in spite of recent work showing moderate drinking does not provide a cardiovascular benefit. "Even if it were true," she says, "the idea that people are going to drink only one or two drinks a day as medication for the rest of their lives is just ridiculous. We`ve been sold an idea that`s incoherent."



Comments

m1.png m2.png m3.png m4.png m5.png
f1.png f2.png f3.png f4.png f5.png
+ =
  • wineyard!
    March 22, 2016, 11:17 pm
    What this study tells us is that there is not enough difference to matter. Even if they can coax statistical significance from the data somehow, it will never be clinically or practically significant. Same goes for hormone replacement causing/preventing cancer, statins causing/preventing cataracts, etc etc. If a giant study observing thousands of people for a decade can`t settle the issue decisively, then it`s a wash. Everyone move on.
  • HI5
    March 22, 2016, 11:16 pm
    Industry wins. Health wins. Industry wins. Health wins......
  • Kriso
    March 22, 2016, 11:16 pm
    Whatever the health tidbit flavor of the day is, as per usual. That`s why I believe in sticking to the "moderation is key" adage.
  • Barak obozo
    March 22, 2016, 11:15 pm
    I wish the media would stop reporting on every new study that comes along. They rarely, if ever, put in any context for the teeming masses, and, as a result, the teeming masses take it as "truth". Half the time it is BS.
    • Fit Guy
      March 23, 2016, 2:12 pm
      You can read two opposite studies on every issue in the same time. Listen to your body, it tells u what to it and drink to be fine
  • bumblebeast
    March 22, 2016, 11:15 pm
    There aren`t any health benefits to drinking beer and...I don`t need any.
  • ian
    March 22, 2016, 11:15 pm
    I`ll enjoy my wine and not worry about it. We worry too much when the end result is predictable to begin with...we all die. Enjoy life.
  • goodfroi
    March 22, 2016, 11:13 pm
    Ignore the grumps. In vino, veritas.....every time. I enjoy all types of music. And..I make it my business to laugh loudly 3 or 4 times daily. I eat meat, eggs and drink coffee. And when friends come over to play poker on fri nights? I smoke a cigar and..hit a toke or 2 of that sticky ikky (marijuana) My wife and I..still play around in the bed too! My doctor says my health status is great. Live your Life people. You`re gonna look real stupid lying there in bed dying..of good health!
  • michael
    March 22, 2016, 11:13 pm
    Lookahere folks, I`m 65. I exercise 5 days a week, eat well (having my occasional bowl of ice cream and a dark chocolate brownie weekly). And I don`t trip/worry about issues. Whether they be politics or life. I drink combos of Merlot/cabernet 2 or 4 times a weekly. At least 2 glasses every time. I enjoy all types of music. And..I make it my business to laugh loudly 3 or 4 times daily. I eat meat, eggs and drink coffee. And when friends come over to play poker on fri nights? I smoke a cigar and..hit a toke or 2 of that sticky ikky (marijuana) My wife and I..still play around in the bed too! My doctor says my health status is great. Live your Life people. You`re gonna look real stupid lying there in bed dying..of good health!
  • Levski SF
    March 22, 2016, 9:30 pm
    My grandfather used ti drink 1-2 kilos red wine every day and died at 101 with clear mind. And also don`t forget that drunk wife make all house happy Cheers